Book Critique blogger.com Loading Examples: entirely, completely. 2. Remove extreme language in most cases. Some examples are “all,” “always,” “never,” “forever.” 3. When you come across a sentence that expresses an opinion, feeling, or judgment, ask yourself, “Is this true?” Do this for facts, as well. WRITING. You have some very fine writing in this book · Research is another important part of writing the book critique. Read up on the author, the times that he lived in and what factors were prevalent in society when he wrote the book. For instance, most of Thomas Hardy’s novels are a historical reflection of the condition of the poor and rural people in the Victorian Era
Book Review Examples and How To Write A Book Review
It was a pleasure to read your novel, The X Game. The title itself evokes a sense of play and mystery—What is the X? And what kind of game is it? In critiquing your novel, I read it first as a reader, then again as an editor.
Although you will find occasional example of book critique inserted in bubbles in the electronic manuscript, the majority of my feedback is summarized here in this critique.
I will close this critique with my editorial recommendations and final words. This has all the elements of a classic horror story. From the beginning, the main character, a leader of a mysterious order, turns off the security system inside the manor, immediately cueing the reader that the protagonist is about to do something clandestine.
There is an underground tunnel and secret doors, and rumors of frightful things inside the forest. You wisely start in the middle of the action and propel the protagonist—and the reader—into the unknown, which we know is going to be dangerous.
There are encounters—with a mysterious creature and an attack by wolves—that keep the action going and the reader reading—all good. After Egri is rescued by Jordan perhaps too conveniently? and taken to the manor, he is confronted by a stranger—Marlo—who is the one who summoned him in the first place. What Egri does not know, but we readers know, is that Marlo is not a normal human being.
In fact, he too is a supernatural creature, possibly a vampire. In other words, the protagonist is not really safe nor is he in an ordinary place, but rather he has entered an extraordinary world, and that as much as he wishes to turn back, it is too late. Overall, the plot is unfolding naturally—or perhaps I should say, example of book critique, classically. The danger in taking this approach is that example of book critique sophisticated reader of horror is not going to find much example of book critique that is fresh and new in the way of storytelling.
Egri is a transparent and expressive character who does not hesitate to act, speak, or run away if he has to. His frank manner makes him easily knowable and perhaps, for some, relatable and even comical.
In a sense, he is your average man who is put into extraordinary circumstances. As a reader I want to know how the protagonist is going to react and cope with all that happens to him. In other words, I want to know if he is going to survive his ordeal and how he will be changed by it.
Having said that, however, I noticed that there are times when Egri over-expresses verbally and physically, by shouting, talking to himself, and so on, which can have a theatrical and cartoony effect. Sometimes, subtle words and gestures can be just as effective in conveying fear, horror, and anger. Marlo is the second major character and he is intriguing, because not only is he a vampire, but a remorseful one.
That in itself makes him rise a bit above the stock vampires you see in fiction and movies. As a reader, I want to know more about him and what he has done in the past and what he hopes to do to rectify his past sins, example of book critique. I suggest developing this further in subsequent chapters. I think this approach works fine, as long as it remains consistent throughout the novel. The setting is atmospheric and effective. The important thing here is to make sure the weather is consistent.
Also, Marlo is looking out at a city skyline. This was unexpected, since the way the beginning is written, it seems we are in the remote countryside, where there are forests that go on for miles. Something to think about. Voice is partly how characters speak as well as how the story is written.
I found that the most glaring inconsistency in voice is in the leader's diction. I have flagged these areas in the manuscript for your review. Regarding tone, this changes depending on whose POV we are following. What to be careful of is overstressing tone by using ALL CAPS or exclamation points. There are other, subtler ways to convey tone via gestures, physical details, metaphors, rhythm, and so on.
Above, I briefly mentioned rhythm. Rhythm involves pacing and timing. Sentences have a rhythm, as do paragraphs and scenes. The dread and horror of the scenes are not effectively conveyed—and horror relies heavily on timing and pacing to scare readers. So, I recommend that you rewrite those areas, example of book critique, keeping in mind pacing and timing—to create surprise, horror, and dread—the hallmark emotions in horror fiction.
Most of my editorial recommendations have already been given, but to summarize here, I think what you have written is a contemporary Gothic horror story that, with some refinements, will no doubt find avid readers of genre fiction. The question you may need to ask yourself is, example of book critique, Do I want to give readers something new?
If so, you may have to rethink the tropes and motifs you are using and reimagine this story differently, so as to surprise and satisfy the more sophisticated example of book critique of horror fiction. Whatever you decide, I recommend revising the manuscript, keeping in mind my comments and suggestions.
After that, the next step would be to either submit this to an agent who specializes in horror fiction or self-publish, if that is your intention. If you decide to self-publish, I recommend having your book copyedited and proofread to ensure that your book is error-free prior to publication. It was a pleasure to work on your book, My Hollywood, example of book critique. As a reader I learned a great deal about the impact of consumer culture on women and the empty feminine ideals it promotes.
And I learned much about youa writer, thinker, and woman who has been brave enough to pull all the stops and reflect on your upbringing and analyze the forces that have influenced your life. The voice you write with is smart, wisecracking, and honest; a voice that young women today can relate with. I think your book will speak to many women who struggle with the same issues you once faced [ What follows is an overview of the strengths and weaknesses of your manuscript and includes editorial recommendations on what and how to revise it.
Be prepared to do several more rounds of revisions, with each revision bringing your book closer to perfection and the fulfillment of your vision. The structure you have now is not consistently linear, and the links from one topic to the next are not often clear.
Breaking up your book into three acts works fine. Starting Act I after the introductory chapter is good. And having Act II at the start of your college years is also a good choice. But I suggest moving chapter 6 to Act II since it deals with your college years, not high school.
As for Act III, consider starting it at chapter 18—which is example of book critique your stint as a script reader, example of book critique. The last sentence of chapter 17 rings a satisfying death knell for the end of Act II and segues nicely to chapter I also recommend creating a new chapter—between chapters 3 and 4—that focuses on [ I also suggest breaking up chapter 4 into two separate chapters see page example of book critique of your manuscript.
Mixing memoir with analysis is tricky. The challenge is to stay objective while at the same time write about things you feel strongly about. When there's too much subjectivity in example of book critique writing, the author loses credibility. Readers will start to distrust what example of book critique author is saying and feel like they're being manipulated to feel, think, believe what the writer so strongly feels, thinks, and believes.
I can see this happening in your book, example of book critique. One trick is to write about yourself in third person, then later rewrite it in first person. By initially writing in third person, it allows you to see yourself as a character—to observe without judgment and instead with curiosity and insight. This would require hard work on your part, but it is a method that some memoirists use when writing autobiography.
I know that sounds contradictory, but what I mean is, when you write about your mistakes and failings, try to do it without judgment. Let the facts speak for themselves. When it comes to your research and analysis, make sure to recheck all your quotes and example of book critique. Also, example of book critique, fact-check everything. I noticed that example of book critique tend to speculate and make educated guesses. These are okay some of the time, but make sure you have evidence to support them.
I flag a few of these in the manuscript. Also, I noticed that certain topics are revisited more than once. Sometimes this is okay if kept short and to a minimum. Some of what I wrote in the preceding paragraph applies here as well. Your writing voice is smart, sassy, and witty, and conveys your distinct personality. However, there are times when your voice comes across as too emotional and judgmental.
Also, there is liberal use of example of book critique and exaggerated language, which tends to undermine the credibility of your argument. Here are three easy tricks to tone down your writing:.
Find all adverbs ending in —ly and example of book critique most of them. Recast the sentence without them and see if the sentence reads calmer and clearer, example of book critique.
Adverbs tend to exaggerate, so use them only when necessary. Examples: entirely, completely. Remove extreme language in most cases. You have some very fine writing in this book. And you present a persuasive argument. You also do a great job of expressing your personality through your choice of words and examples, example of book critique.
As this is a developmental edit, not a copyedit, I did not edit the language except on occasion when I thought it would be helpful by showing you how to revise a sentence or paragraph.
How to Write a Critique Essay (An Evaluation Essay_
, time: 9:26How To Write A Book Critique for College
book critique. NOTE: the title of each part below also indicates what % of your word count should be dedicated to each section. Part 1: Introduce Work and Author Details (5%) • Provide information on the author/s. Be factual and relevant. • Establish the specific qualifications that qualify him/her to speak on the topic. Part 2: Purpose of the Book (5%) • Summarise the aim/s or purpose of the book Book Review – Introduction As good examples of book review show, the intro should not be long, since the main argument will be developed in the body. Nevertheless, the intro includes valuable info that attributes the book and gives some insight into who the author is. Try to include the following points (not as a list, but as full sentences) An analytic or critical review of a book or article is not primarily a summary; rather, it comments on and evaluates the work in the light of specific issues and theoretical concerns in a course. (To help sharpen your analytical reading skills, see our file on Critical Reading.)The literature review puts together a set of such commentaries to map out the current range of positions on a topic
No comments:
Post a Comment